top of page

Fast Action Needed: Protect the federal laws that give communities a voice

Nov 8
6 min read

Updated: Nov 14


Senate Bill Would Roll Back Our Nation’s Core Environmental and Historic Preservation Laws


The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act would silence communities, landowners, and Tribal Nations and weaken requirements to avoid, reduce, and mitigate the impacts of major infrastructure projects.


To meet unchecked data center energy demand, Virginia continues to make critical decisions about the largest buildout of transmission lines, substations, and gas plants in the state’s history. So far, the state has passed on pausing data centers and transmission lines to plan for their impacts on public health, quality of life, historic and cultural sites, and natural resources.

And now, Congress is proposing to make things worse.


Within the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (S. 5653), Congress is considering sweeping legislation that would significantly weaken some of the nation’s core environmental and historic preservation laws – rolling back oversight and muting the voices of communities that these large energy infrastructure projects will impact.


Most concerning are the proposed changes to the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) and National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). Still, the bill would also affect the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act.


These laws currently ensure that federal agencies minimize and mitigate a project’s impacts and hear from affected communities before it moves forward. Passing the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act would mean fewer projects get reviewed at all, and the voices of the people who live with the results would be stifled.


The Senate is expected to vote on the bill Monday, Nov. 9. The House could decide to take up the bill shortly afterward, in order to push the legislation through before new members of Congress take office in January.

Please take two minutes to tell your U.S. senators and representatives to vote NO on S. 5653 and protect our core environmental and historic preservation laws.


Every day, federal agencies plan, fund, and permit highways, pipelines, transmission lines, cell towers, and mining and development projects that affect historic and sacred places, significant viewsheds, habitat, wetlands and waterways. 


Without careful review, planning, and input from the people and communities most affected, these projects can destroy what makes a place special: national parks and historic main streets, family cemeteries, scenic rivers and mountain views, and sites sacred to Tribal Nations.


For 60 years, NEPA and Section 106 of the NHPA have required federal agencies to consider how projects they fund or permit will impact natural resources and historic places. These laws have also guaranteed that local communities, property owners, and Tribal Nations are consulted before decisions are final. Section 106 and NEPA are two of the few legal tools that still protect that public voice. And they are gravely at risk.

Among other things, S. 5653 would:

 

  • Shut out the public. Not only would residents, property owners, and local governments no longer be guaranteed a role in reviews, but they would learn about decisions only after they’re made, and they could be barred from challenging those decisions in court for failing to raise concerns earlier. How could they have raised concerns when they were kept out of the conversation?

  • Ignore whole categories of impact. Noise and visual impacts would no longer matter. Neither would impacts to natural landscape features like mountains and rivers or sacred ancestral sites. And the cumulative impacts of other past, present, or planned projects in the same area would not be considered.

  • Make protecting historic places optional. Agencies could acknowledge damage and then decline to avoid or reduce it.

  • Let agencies undercut or ignore tribal consultation at their own discretion and put sacred sites at risk.

  • Limit what judges can do. Even when an agency breaks the law, judges could not stop a project for violating NEPA or the NHPA They could only send the decision back to the agency, while construction continues.

  • Review fewer projects. Both laws would only apply to projects that agencies decide are under “substantial federal control,” and many federally funded projects would be excluded entirely. Agencies could skip a NEPA review if a state review or another federal process “serves a similar function.”

  • Exempt transmission lines and pipelines in existing corridors. Rebuilds, upgrades and limited expansions of transmission lines and gas pipelines in existing rights-of-way would get no environmental or historic review, even when new towers more than double the height of the old ones.

 

The entities pushing this bill argue that environmental and historic preservation reviews, and the lawsuits that follow them, tie up major projects for years, particularly massive high-voltage interstate transmission lines and gas pipelines.


But the numbers tell a different story. In their open letter to Congress, the firm Cultural Heritage Partners states that, of the more than 120,000 federal projects that go through a Section 106 review each year, only about eight end up in court. They go on to say that the real causes of delay are developers providing incomplete information at the start of the review process and waiting too long to consult. Shutting the public out only means problems come to light later, after construction has started, when fixing them is far more expensive and far more likely to end up in court.


Rally at the Capitol on Nov. 9: Join a growing coalition of people and organizations at the U.S. Capitol on Monday, Nov. 9, for the “106 Strong Rally” to stand up for the places that tell our story. This event is hosted by Cultural Heritage Partners. Learn more and RSVP.

 

Write your members of Congress

 

Success Stories Close to Home

The towers on the James River (left) were built, but Section 106 ensured the public got something back through mitigation: the creation of Machicomoco State Park (right), which honors Virginia’s Indigenous peoples.

 

 Over my three decades of work at PEC, I’ve seen firsthand how laws like Section 106 have given communities in Virginia a voice in protecting the resources they care deeply about:

  • On the James River: Dominion Energy built a transmission line with 17 steel towers that blocked views from Jamestown Island. Preservation groups, with PEC’s help, challenged the inadequate environmental and Section 106 reviews and prevailed in court. The project was built, but as part of mitigation, Dominion was required to donate $25 million for regional land conservation and the creation of Machicomoco State Park–honoring Virginia’s Indigenous peoples.

  • Near Manassas National Battlefield Park: In 1993, the Walt Disney Co. proposed a theme park and massive real estate development less than 4 miles from the battlefield where two Civil War battles were fought. Grassroots activists, led by PEC, fought back and prevailed, arguing the theme park and development would ruin the historic landscape. Because the project needed federal wetland permits and federal funding for new highway interchanges and the widening of I-66, it required NEPA and Section 106 reviews. Those reviews became some of the most important tools for showing the public the harm the project would cause.

  • In Albemarle County: A proposed Route 29 western bypass threatened the historic home and family cemetery of the Sammons family, descendants of the Hemings family of Monticello and leaders of a thriving post-Civil War Black community. The sites’ eligibility for the National Register of Historic Places triggered a Section 106 review that included PEC and the descendant community and encouraged the Virginia Department of Transportation, the county and communities to propose alternatives. The bypass was eventually shelved in favor of improvements to the Route 29 corridor that have helped focus development and improve traffic flow.

 

What’s Coming Next

As I said at the beginning, over the next two decades, Virginia may be planning the largesbuild-out of transmission infrastructure in our history, detrimentally impacting historic sites and our nation’s treasured landscapes, clean water, wildlife habitat,at and farmland.

Over the past three years, our communities have been forced to respond to many new transmission line proposals, including the Golden-Mars line in Loudoun County, the Valley Link Joshua Falls-Yeat line through Orange County and into Culpeper County, the Valley North line through Clarke and Loudoun counties, the Morrisville-Wishingstar line in Fauquier, Prince William and Loudoun counties, and Charlottesville-Gordonsville in Albemarle and Orange counties. 

Many more proposals are likely as the energy demand from new data centers increases. Projections show Virginia’s energy infrastructure could need to grow by as much as five times the size of the current system just to serve data centers. As these projects multiply, the protections in federal law will matter more than ever.  

Yet those protections are threatened on several fronts. Beyond S. 5653, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation is proposing its own rule changes to weaken Section 106.

Taken together, these efforts are part of a broader and deeply concerning trend: fewer questions asked, less information shared and fewer opportunities for the people most affected to be heard.

The places we love were not protected by accident. They were protected because people showed up and spoke up. Let’s make sure we keep that right.

Other Resources:

Send your letter now →

 


 

Comments


bottom of page